Ideal timeframes for operating on traumatic stretch and blunt brachial plexus injuries remain a topic of debate. Whereas on the one hand spontaneous recovery might occur, on the other hand, long delays are believed to result in poorer functional outcomes. The goal of this review is to assess the optimal timeframe for surgical intervention for traumatic brachial plexus injuries.
A systematic search was performed in January 2017 in PubMed and Embase databases according to the PRISMA guidelines. Search terms related to “brachial plexus injury” and “timing” were used. Obstetric plexus palsies were excluded. Qualitative synthesis was performed on all studies. Timing of operation and motor outcome were collected from individual patient data. Patients were categorized into 5 delay groups (0–3, 3–6, 6–9, 9–12, and > 12 months). Median delays were calculated for Medical Research Council (MRC) muscle grade ≥ 3 and ≥ 4 recoveries.
Forty-three studies were included after full-text screening. Most articles showed significantly better motor outcome with delays to surgery less than 6 months, with some studies specifying even shorter delays. Pain and quality of life scores were also significantly better with shorter delays. Nerve reconstructions performed after long time intervals, even more than 12 months, can still be useful. All papers reporting individual-level patient data described a combined total of 569 patients; 65.5% of all patients underwent operations within 6 months and 27.4% within 3 months. The highest percentage of ≥ MRC grade 3 (89.7%) was observed in the group operated on within 3 months. These percentages decreased with longer delays, with only 35.7% ≥ MRC grade 3 with delays > 12 months. A median delay of 4 months (IQR 3–6 months) was observed for a recovery of ≥ MRC grade 3, compared with a median delay of 7 months (IQR 5–11 months) for ≤ MRC grade 3 recovery.
The results of this systematic review show that in stretch and blunt injury of the brachial plexus, the optimal time to surgery is shorter than 6 months. In general, a 3-month delay appears to be appropriate because while recovery is better in those operated on earlier, this must be considered given the potential for spontaneous recovery.
ABBREVIATIONSAFRS = average final result of surgery; DASH = Disability of the Arm, Shoulder and Hand questionnaire; IQR = interquartile range; MRC = Medical Research Council; PRISMA = Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analysis; SF-36 = 36-Item Short-Form Health Survey; VAS = visual analog scale.
AllieuYChammasMPicotMC: [Paralysis of the brachial plexus caused by supraclavicular injuries in the adult. Long-term comparative results of nerve grafts and transfers.]Rev Chir Orthop Repar Appar Mot83:51–591997 (Fr)
BarthelPYBarbarySBretonAApredoaeiCDapFMansatP: [Recovery of elbow flexion in post-traumatic C5-C6 and C5-C6-C7 palsy: retrospective dual-center study comparing single and double nerve transfer.]Chir Main33:211–2182014 (Fr)
CouletBBorettoJGLazergesCChammasM: A comparison of intercostal and partial ulnar nerve transfers in restoring elbow flexion following upper brachial plexus injury (C5-C6±C7). J Hand Surg Am35:1297–13032010
DolanRTButlerJSMurphySMHynesDCroninKJ: Health-related quality of life and functional outcomes following nerve transfers for traumatic upper brachial plexus injuries. J Hand Surg Eur Vol. 37:642–6512012
SocolovskyMMartinsRSDi MasiGBonillaGSiqueiraMG: Influence of body mass index on the outcome of brachial plexus surgery: are there any differences between elbow and shoulder results?Acta Neurochir (Wien)156:2337–23442014
SouzaFHMBernardinoSNFilhoHCAGobbatoPLMartinsRSMartinsHAL: Comparison between the anterior and posterior approach for transfer of the spinal accessory nerve to the suprascapular nerve in late traumatic brachial plexus injuries. Acta Neurochir (Wien)156:2345–23492014
TuYKTsaiYJChangCHSuFCHsiaoCKTanJSW: Surgical treatment for total root avulsion type brachial plexus injuries by neurotization: a prospective comparison study between total and hemicontralateral C7 nerve root transfer. Microsurgery34:91–1012014
VenkatramaniHBhardwajPFaruqueeSRSabapathySR: Functional outcome of nerve transfer for restoration of shoulder and elbow function in upper brachial plexus injury. J Brachial Plex Peripher Nerve Inj3:152008
XiaoCLaoJWangTZhaoXLiuJGuY: Intercostal nerve transfer to neurotize the musculocutaneous nerve after traumatic brachial plexus avulsion: a comparison of two, three, and four nerve transfers. J Reconstr Microsurg30:297–3042014