Meningiomas treated by subtotal or partial resection are associated with significantly shorter recurrence-free survival than those treated by gross-total resection. The Simpson grading system classifies incomplete resections into a single category, namely Simpson Grade IV, with wide variations in the volume and location of residual tumors, making it complicated to evaluate the achievement of surgical goals and predict the prognosis of these tumors. Authors of the present study investigated the factors related to necessity of retreatment and tried to identify any surgical nuances achievable with the aid of modern neurosurgical techniques for meningiomas treated using Simpson Grade IV resection.
This retrospective analysis included patients with WHO Grade I meningiomas treated using Simpson Grade IV resection as the initial therapy at the University of Tokyo Hospital between January 1995 and April 2010. Retreatment was defined as reresection or stereotactic radiosurgery due to postoperative tumor growth.
A total of 38 patients were included in this study. Regrowth of residual tumor was observed in 22 patients with a mean follow-up period of 6.1 years. Retreatment was performed for 20 of these 22 tumors with regrowth. Risk factors related to significantly shorter retreatment-free survival were age younger than 50 years (p = 0.006), postresection tumor volume of 4 cm3 or more (p = 0.016), no dural detachment (p = 0.001), and skull base location (p = 0.016). Multivariate analysis revealed that no dural detachment (hazard ratio [HR] 6.42, 95% CI 1.41–45.0; p = 0.02) and skull base location (HR 11.6, 95% CI 2.18–218; p = 0.002) were independent risk factors for the necessity of early retreatment, whereas postresection tumor volume of 4 cm3 or more was not a statistically significant risk factor.
Compared with Simpson Grade I, II, and III resections, Simpson Grade IV resection includes highly heterogeneous tumors in terms of resection rate and location of the residual mass. Despite the difficulty in analyzing such diverse data, these results draw attention to the favorable effect of dural detachment (instead of maximizing the resection rate) on long-term tumor control. Surgical strategy with an emphasis on detaching the tumor from the affected dura might be another important option in resection of high-risk meningiomas not amenable to gross-total resection.
Abbreviations used in this paper:HR = hazard ratio; KPS = Karnofsky Performance Scale; RFS = retreatment-free survival.
HashimotoNRaboCSOkitaYKinoshitaMKagawaNFujimotoY: Slower growth of skull base meningiomas compared with non-skull base meningiomas based on volumetric and biological studies. Clinical article. J Neurosurg116:574–5802012
IchinoseTGotoTIshibashiKTakamiTOhataK: The role of radical microsurgical resection in multimodal treatment for skull base meningioma. Clinical article. J Neurosurg113:1072–10782010. (Erratum in J Neurosurg 113: 1123 2010)
JääskeläinenJ: Seemingly complete removal of histologically benign intracranial meningioma: late recurrence rate and factors predicting recurrence in 657 patients. A multivariate analysis. Surg Neurol26:461–4691986
McGovernSLAldapeKDMunsellMFMahajanADeMonteFWooSY: A comparison of World Health Organization tumor grades at recurrence in patients with non-skull base and skull base meningiomas. Clinical article. J Neurosurg112:925–9332010
OyaSKawaiKNakatomiHSaitoN: Significance of Simpson grading system in modern meningioma surgery: integration of the grade with MIB-1 labeling index as a key to predict the recurrence of WHO Grade I meningiomas. Clinical article. J Neurosurg117:121–1282012
SughrueMEKaneAJShangariGRutkowskiMJMcDermottMWBergerMS: The relevance of Simpson Grade I and II resection in modern neurosurgical treatment of World Health Organization Grade I meningiomas. Clinical article. J Neurosurg113:1029–10352010
WilliamsBJYenCPStarkeRMBasinaBNguyenJRaineyJ: Gamma Knife surgery for parasellar meningiomas: long-term results including complications, predictive factors, and progression-free survival. Clinical article. J Neurosurg114:1571–15772011