Boxing and mixed martial arts: preliminary traumatic neuromechanical injury risk analyses from laboratory impact dosage data

Laboratory investigation

View More View Less
  • 1 Spine Research Laboratory and
  • 3 Department of Neurological Surgery, Neurological Institute, Cleveland Clinic;
  • 2 Cleveland Traumatic Neuromechanics Consortium;
  • 6 Department of Mechanical Engineering, Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland;
  • 5 Scientific Expert Analysis (SEA), Ltd., Columbus, Ohio; and
  • 4 United Hospital Center Neurosurgery & Spine Center, Clarksburg, West Virginia
Restricted access

Purchase Now

USD  $45.00

JNS + Pediatrics - 1 year subscription bundle (Individuals Only)

USD  $505.00

JNS + Pediatrics + Spine - 1 year subscription bundle (Individuals Only)

USD  $600.00
Print or Print + Online

Object

In spite of ample literature pointing to rotational and combined impact dosage being key contributors to head and neck injury, boxing and mixed martial arts (MMA) padding is still designed to primarily reduce cranium linear acceleration. The objects of this study were to quantify preliminary linear and rotational head impact dosage for selected boxing and MMA padding in response to hook punches; compute theoretical skull, brain, and neck injury risk metrics; and statistically compare the protective effect of various glove and head padding conditions.

Methods

An instrumented Hybrid III 50th percentile anthropomorphic test device (ATD) was struck in 54 pendulum impacts replicating hook punches at low (27–29 J) and high (54–58 J) energy. Five padding combinations were examined: unpadded (control), MMA glove–unpadded head, boxing glove–unpadded head, unpadded pendulum–boxing headgear, and boxing glove–boxing headgear. A total of 17 injury risk parameters were measured or calculated.

Results

All padding conditions reduced linear impact dosage. Other parameters significantly decreased, significantly increased, or were unaffected depending on padding condition. Of real-world conditions (MMA glove–bare head, boxing glove–bare head, and boxing glove–headgear), the boxing glove–headgear condition showed the most meaningful reduction in most of the parameters. In equivalent impacts, the MMA glove–bare head condition induced higher rotational dosage than the boxing glove–bare head condition. Finite element analysis indicated a risk of brain strain injury in spite of significant reduction of linear impact dosage.

Conclusions

In the replicated hook punch impacts, all padding conditions reduced linear but not rotational impact dosage. Head and neck dosage theoretically accumulates fastest in MMA and boxing bouts without use of protective headgear. The boxing glove–headgear condition provided the best overall reduction in impact dosage. More work is needed to develop improved protective padding to minimize linear and rotational impact dosage and develop next-generation standards for head and neck injury risk.

Abbreviations used in this paper:ATD = anthropomorphic test device; CSDM05 = cumulative strain damage measure at the 0.05 level; DDM = dilatational damage measure; GAMBIT = Generalized Acceleration Model for Brain Injury Threshold; GSI = Gadd Severity Index; HIC = Head Injury Criterion; HIP = head impact power; MMA = mixed martial arts; RMDM = relative motion damage measure; SIMon = Simulated Injury Monitor; wPCS = weighted principle component score.

JNS + Pediatrics - 1 year subscription bundle (Individuals Only)

USD  $505.00

JNS + Pediatrics + Spine - 1 year subscription bundle (Individuals Only)

USD  $600.00

Contributor Notes

Address correspondence to: Adam J. Bartsch, Ph.D., Cleveland Clinic Spine Research Laboratory, Luth2-C, 1730 West 25th Street, Cleveland, Ohio 44113. email: bartsca@ccf.org.

Please include this information when citing this paper: published online February 7, 2012; DOI: 10.3171/2011.12.JNS111478.

  • 1

    American Society for Testing and Materials: Standard Test Methods for Equipment and Procedures Used in Evaluating the Performance Characteristics of Protective Headgear. Designation: F1446-01a West Conshohocken, PA, ASTM International, 2002

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 2

    Bandak FA, , Zhang AX, , Tannous RE, , DiMasi F, , Masiello P, & Eppinger R: SIMon: a simulated injury monitor; application to head injury assessment. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) Website (http://www-nrd.nhtsa.dot.gov/pdf/esv/esv17/proceed/00222.pdf) [Accessed January 12, 2012]

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 3

    Broglio SP, , Ju YY, , Broglio MD, & Sell TC: The efficacy of soccer headgear. J Athl Train 38:220224, 2003

  • 4

    Casson IR, , Pellman EJ, & Viano DC: Concussion in the National Football League: an overview for neurologists. Phys Med Rehabil Clin N Am 20:195214, x, 2009

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 5

    Caswell SV, & Deivert RG: Lacrosse helmet designs and the effects of impact forces. J Athl Train 37:164171, 2002

  • 6

    Duma SM, , Manoogian SJ, , Bussone WR, , Brolinson PG, , Goforth MW, & Donnenwerth JJ, : Analysis of real-time head accelerations in collegiate football players. Clin J Sport Med 15:38, 2005

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 7

    Finan JD, , Nightingale RW, & Myers BS: The influence of reduced friction on head injury metrics in helmeted head impacts. Traffic Inj Prev 9:483488, 2008

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 8

    Fréchède B, & McIntosh AS: Numerical reconstruction of real-life concussive football impacts. Med Sci Sports Exerc 41:390398, 2009

  • 9

    Gadd CW: Use of a weighted-impulse criterion for estimating injury hazard. Proceedings of the 10th Stapp Car Crash Conference New York, Society of Automotive Engineers, 1966. 10:164174

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 10

    Gilchrist A, & Mills NJ: Protection of the side of the head. Accid Anal Prev 28:525535, 1996

  • 11

    Greenwald RM, , Gwin JT, , Chu JJ, & Crisco JJ: Head impact severity measures for evaluating mild traumatic brain injury risk exposure. Neurosurgery 62:789798, 2008

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 12

    Hrysomallis C: Impact energy attenuation of protective football headgear against a yielding surface. J Sci Med Sport 7:156164, 2004

  • 13

    Knouse CL, , Gould TE, , Caswell SV, & Deivert RG: Efficacy of rugby headgear in attenuating repetitive linear impact forces. J Athl Train 38:330335, 2003

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 14

    Lewis LM, , Naunheim R, , Standeven J, , Lauryssen C, , Richter C, & Jeffords B: Do football helmets reduce acceleration of impact in blunt head injuries?. Acad Emerg Med 8:604609, 2001

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 15

    Margulies SS, & Thibault LE: A proposed tolerance criterion for diffuse axonal injury in man. J Biomech 25:917923, 1992

  • 16

    McElhaney JH: In search of head injury criteria. Stapp Car Crash J 49:vxvi, 2005

  • 17

    McIntosh A, , McCrory P, & Finch CF: Performance enhanced headgear: a scientific approach to the development of protective headgear. Br J Sports Med 38:4649, 2004

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 18

    McIntosh AS, & McCrory P: Impact energy attenuation performance of football headgear. Br J Sports Med 34:337341, 2000

  • 19

    National Operating Committee on Standards for Athletic Equipment (NOCSAE): Standard test method and equipment used in evaluating the performance characteristics of protective headgear/equipment. NOCSAE Website (http://www.nocsae.org/standards/pdfs/Standards%20'10/ND001-08m10-Drop%20Impact%20Test%20Method%20.pdf) [Accessed January 12, 2012]

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 20

    Naunheim RS, , Ryden A, , Standeven J, , Genin G, , Lewis L, & Thompson P, : Does soccer headgear attenuate the impact when heading a soccer ball?. Acad Emerg Med 10:8590, 2003

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 21

    Newman JA, , Beusenberg MC, , Shewchenko N, , Withnall C, & Fournier E: Verification of biomechanical methods employed in a comprehensive study of mild traumatic brain injury and the effectiveness of American football helmets. J Biomech 38:14691481, 2005

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 22

    Newman JA, , Shewchenko N, & Welbourne E: A proposed new biomechanical head injury assessment function—the maximum power index. Snell Memorial Foundation Website (http://www.smf.org/docs/articles/hic/Newman_Max_Power_Index.pdf) [Accessed January 12, 2012]

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 23

    Ommaya AK, , Goldsmith W, & Thibault L: Biomechanics and neuropathology of adult and paediatric head injury. Br J Neurosurg 16:220242, 2002

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 24

    Ommaya AK, & Hirsch AE: Tolerances for cerebral concussion from head impact and whiplash in primates. J Biomech 4:1321, 1971

  • 25

    Pellman EJ, , Viano DC, , Tucker AM, , Casson IR, & Waeckerle JF: Concussion in professional football: reconstruction of game impacts and injuries. Neurosurgery 53:799814, 2003

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 26

    Smith PK, & Hamill J: The effect of punching glove type and skill level on momentum-transfer. J Hum Mov Stud 12:153161, 1986

  • 27

    Smith TA, , Bishop PJ, & Wells RP: Three dimensional analysis of linear and angular accelerations of the head experienced in boxing. Proceedings of the International Research Council on Biomechanics of Impact Vol 1:Bergish-Gladbach, Germany, IRCOBI, 19731989, 271286

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 28

    Snell Memorial Foundation: Standard for protective headgear for use in non-motorized sports. Snell Memorial Foundation Website (http://www.smf.org/standards/n94/n94std) [Accessed January 12, 2012]

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 29

    Society of Automotive Engineers: SAE Information Report. Sign Convention for Vehicle Crash Testing—SAE J1733 Warrendale, PA, Society of Automotive Engineers, 1994

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 30

    Society of Automotive Engineers: SAE Recommended Practice. Instrumentation for Impact Test—Part 1—Electronic Instrumentation—SAE J211/1 Warrendale, PA, Society of Automotive Engineers, 1995

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 31

    Stojsih S, , Boitano M, , Wilhelm M, & Bir C: A prospective study of punch biomechanics and cognitive function for amateur boxers. Br J Sports Med 44:725730, 2010

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 32

    Takhounts EG, , Eppinger RH, , Campbell JQ, , Tannous RE, , Power ED, & Shook LS: On the development of the SIMon finite element head model. Stapp Car Crash J 47:107133, 2003

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 33

    Thibault LE, & Gennarelli TA: Brain injury: an analysis of neural and neurovascular trauma in the non-human primate. Ann Proc Assoc Adv Automot Med 34:337351, 1990

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 34

    Tierney RT, , Higgins M, , Caswell SV, , Brady J, , McHardy K, & Driban JB, : Sex differences in head acceleration during heading while wearing soccer headgear. J Athl Train 43:578584, 2008

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 35

    Versace J: A review of the severity index. Proceedings of the 15th Stapp Car Crash Conference New York, Society of Automotive Engineers, 1971. 771796

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 36

    Viano DC, , Casson IR, , Pellman EJ, , Bir CA, , Zhang L, & Sherman DC, : Concussion in professional football: comparison with boxing head impacts—part 10. Neurosurgery 57:11541172, 2005

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 37

    Viano DC, , Pellman EJ, , Withnall C, & Shewchenko N: Concussion in professional football: performance of newer helmets in reconstructed game impacts—part 13. Neurosurgery 59:591606, 2006

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 38

    Walilko TJ, , Viano DC, & Bir CA: Biomechanics of the head for Olympic boxer punches to the face. Br J Sports Med 39:710719, 2005

  • 39

    Withnall C, , Shewchenko N, , Gittens R, & Dvorak J: Biomechanical investigation of head impacts in football. Br J Sports Med 39:Suppl 1 i49i57, 2005

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 40

    Withnall C, , Shewchenko N, , Wonnacott M, & Dvorak J: Effectiveness of headgear in football. Br J Sports Med 39:Suppl 1 i40i48, 2005

  • 41

    Zhang L, , Yang KH, & King AI: A proposed injury threshold for mild traumatic brain injury. J Biomech Eng 126:226236, 2004

Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 1347 616 70
Full Text Views 533 30 2
PDF Downloads 224 16 1
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0