Surgical innovation or surgical evolution: an ethical and practical guide to handling novel neurosurgical procedures

Restricted access

Object. Surgical innovation is an important driver of improvements in technique and technology, which ultimately translates into improvements in patients' outcomes. Nevertheless, patients may face new risks of morbidity and mortality when surgical innovation is used, and well-intentioned surgical “experimentation” on patients must be regulated and monitored. In this paper the authors examine the challenges of defining surgical innovation and briefly review the literature on this challenging subject.

Methods. Using examples from the field of neurosurgery and in part from the personal experience of the senior author, the authors develop a model of levels of experimental acuity of surgical procedures and offer recommendations on how these procedures would best be regulated.

Conclusions. The authors propose guidelines for determining the need for regulation of innovation. The potential role of institutional review boards in this process is highlighted.

Article Information

Address reprint requests to: Mark Bernstein, M.D., Division of Neurosurgery, Toronto Western Hospital, 399 Bathurst Street, 4W451, Toronto, Ontario M5T 2S8, Canada. email: mark.bernstein@uhn.on.ca.

© AANS, except where prohibited by US copyright law.

Headings

References

  • 1.

    Agich GJ: Ethics and innovation in medicine. J Med Ethics 27:2952962001Agich GJ: Ethics and innovation in medicine. J Med Ethics 27:295–296 2001

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 2.

    Al-Anazi ABernstein M: Modified stereotactic insertion of Ommaya reservoir. Technical note. J Neurosurg 92:105010522000Al-Anazi A Bernstein M: Modified stereotactic insertion of Ommaya reservoir. Technical note. J Neurosurg 92:1050–1052 2000

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 3.

    Awad IA: Innovation through minimalism: assessing emerging technology in neurosurgery. Clin Neurosurg 43:3033161996Awad IA: Innovation through minimalism: assessing emerging technology in neurosurgery. Clin Neurosurg 43:303–316 1996

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 4.

    Bampoe JSiomin VBernstein M: Quality-of-life assessment in neurosurgical patients. Neurosurg Q 12:1321412002Bampoe J Siomin V Bernstein M: Quality-of-life assessment in neurosurgical patients. Neurosurg Q 12:132–141 2002

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 5.

    Beauchamp TL: IOM report on the system for protecting human research participants. Kennedy Inst Ethics J 12:3893902002Beauchamp TL: IOM report on the system for protecting human research participants. Kennedy Inst Ethics J 12:389–390 2002

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 6.

    Beech RMorgan M: Constraints on innovatory practice: the case of day surgery in the NHS. Int J Health Plann Manage 7:1331481992Beech R Morgan M: Constraints on innovatory practice: the case of day surgery in the NHS. Int J Health Plann Manage 7:133–148 1992

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 7.

    Bernstein M: Outpatient craniotomy for brain tumor: a pilot feasibility study in 46 patients. Can J Neurol Sci 28:1201242001Bernstein M: Outpatient craniotomy for brain tumor: a pilot feasibility study in 46 patients. Can J Neurol Sci 28:120–124 2001

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 8.

    Bernstein MAl-Anazi ARKucharczyk Wet al: Brain tumor surgery with the Toronto open magnetic resonance imaging system: preliminary results for 36 patients and analysis of advantages, disadvantages, and future prospects. Neurosurgery 46:9009092000Bernstein M Al-Anazi AR Kucharczyk W et al: Brain tumor surgery with the Toronto open magnetic resonance imaging system: preliminary results for 36 patients and analysis of advantages disadvantages and future prospects. Neurosurgery 46:900–909 2000

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 9.

    Bernstein MUpshur REG: Framework for bioethical assessing of an article on therapy. J Neurosurg 98:4854902003Bernstein M Upshur REG: Framework for bioethical assessing of an article on therapy. J Neurosurg 98:485–490 2003

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 10.

    Bernstein MWalters BC: Introduction: Beyond survival: guidelines and outcomes in neurooncology. Neurosurg Focus 4(6):121998Bernstein M Walters BC: Introduction: Beyond survival: guidelines and outcomes in neurooncology. Neurosurg Focus 4(6):1–2 1998

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 11.

    Bhardwaj RDBernstein M: Prospective feasibility study of outpatient stereotactic brain lesion biopsy. Neurosurgery 51:3583642002Bhardwaj RD Bernstein M: Prospective feasibility study of outpatient stereotactic brain lesion biopsy. Neurosurgery 51:358–364 2002

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 12.

    Blancquaert IDe Langavant GCBouchard Let al: Oversight mechanisms for technology transfer in molecular genetics. Can J Policy Res 2:1031092001Blancquaert I De Langavant GC Bouchard L et al: Oversight mechanisms for technology transfer in molecular genetics. Can J Policy Res 2:103–109 2001

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 13.

    Blanshard HJChung FManninen PHet al: Awake craniotomy for removal of intracranial tumor: considerations for early discharge. Anesth Analg 92:89942001Blanshard HJ Chung F Manninen PH et al: Awake craniotomy for removal of intracranial tumor: considerations for early discharge. Anesth Analg 92:89–94 2001

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 14.

    Bunker JPHinkley DMcDermott WV: Surgical innovation and its evaluation. Science 200:9379411978Bunker JP Hinkley D McDermott WV: Surgical innovation and its evaluation. Science 200:937–941 1978

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 15.

    Duffner FFreudenstein DHohenstein Fet al: Quality planning for minimally invasive procedures in neurosurgery. Minim Invasive Neurosurg 44:95982001Duffner F Freudenstein D Hohenstein F et al: Quality planning for minimally invasive procedures in neurosurgery. Minim Invasive Neurosurg 44:95–98 2001

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 16.

    The EC/IC Bypass Study Group: Failure of extracranial-intracranial arterial bypass to reduce the risk of ischemic stroke. Results of an international randomized trial. N Engl J Med 313:119112001985The EC/IC Bypass Study Group: Failure of extracranial-intracranial arterial bypass to reduce the risk of ischemic stroke. Results of an international randomized trial. N Engl J Med 313:1191–1200 1985

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 17.

    Emanuel EJWendler DGrady C: What makes clinical research ethical? JAMA 283:270127112000Emanuel EJ Wendler D Grady C: What makes clinical research ethical? JAMA 283:2701–2711 2000

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 18.

    Frader JEFlanagan-Klygis E: Innovation and research in pediatric surgery. Semin Pediatr Surg 10:1982032001Frader JE Flanagan-Klygis E: Innovation and research in pediatric surgery. Semin Pediatr Surg 10:198–203 2001

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 19.

    Gerszten PC: Outcomes research: a review. Neurosurgery 43:114611561998Gerszten PC: Outcomes research: a review. Neurosurgery 43:1146–1156 1998

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 20.

    Gillett G: Ethics of surgical innovation. Br J Surg 88:8978982001Gillett G: Ethics of surgical innovation. Br J Surg 88:897–898 2001

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 21.

    Grimmett MRSulmasy DP: The call of the sirens: ethically navigating the sea of nonvalidated therapies. J Refract Surg 14:5595661998Grimmett MR Sulmasy DP: The call of the sirens: ethically navigating the sea of nonvalidated therapies. J Refract Surg 14:559–566 1998

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 22.

    Guerrissi JO: Innovation and surgical techniques: endoscopic resection of cervical branchiogenic cysts. J Craniofac Surg 13:4784822002Guerrissi JO: Innovation and surgical techniques: endoscopic resection of cervical branchiogenic cysts. J Craniofac Surg 13:478–482 2002

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 23.

    Gutin PHPhillips TLWara WMet al: Brachytherapy of recurrent malignant brain tumors with removable high-activity iodine-125 sources. J Neurosurg 60:61681984Gutin PH Phillips TL Wara WM et al: Brachytherapy of recurrent malignant brain tumors with removable high-activity iodine-125 sources. J Neurosurg 60:61–68 1984

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 24.

    Haines SJ: Randomized clinical trials in the evaluation of surgical innovation. J Neurosurg 51:5111979Haines SJ: Randomized clinical trials in the evaluation of surgical innovation. J Neurosurg 51:5–11 1979

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 25.

    Hashizume MShimada MTomikawa Met al: Early experiences of endoscopic procedures in general surgery assisted by a computer-enhanced surgical system. Surg Endosc 16:118711912002Hashizume M Shimada M Tomikawa M et al: Early experiences of endoscopic procedures in general surgery assisted by a computer-enhanced surgical system. Surg Endosc 16:1187–1191 2002

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 26.

    Hoznek AZaki SKSamadi DBet al: Robotic assisted kidney transplantation: an initial experience. J Urol 167:160416062002Hoznek A Zaki SK Samadi DB et al: Robotic assisted kidney transplantation: an initial experience. J Urol 167:1604–1606 2002

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 27.

    Kondziolka DWechsler LGoldstein Set al: Transplantation of cultured human neuronal cells for patients with stroke. Neurology 55:5655692000Kondziolka D Wechsler L Goldstein S et al: Transplantation of cultured human neuronal cells for patients with stroke. Neurology 55:565–569 2000

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 28.

    Kriss TCKriss VM: History of the operating microscope: from magnifying glass to microneurosurgery. Neurosurgery 42:8999081998Kriss TC Kriss VM: History of the operating microscope: from magnifying glass to microneurosurgery. Neurosurgery 42:899–908 1998

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 29.

    Laperriere NJLeung PMKMcKenzie Set al: Randomized study of brachytherapy in the initial management of patients with malignant astrocytoma. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys 41:100510111998Laperriere NJ Leung PMK McKenzie S et al: Randomized study of brachytherapy in the initial management of patients with malignant astrocytoma. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys 41:1005–1011 1998

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 30.

    McDermott MWCiricillo SFGutin PHet al: Stereotactic insertion of an Ommaya reservoir: technical note. Can J Neurol Sci 22:2352381995McDermott MW Ciricillo SF Gutin PH et al: Stereotactic insertion of an Ommaya reservoir: technical note. Can J Neurol Sci 22:235–238 1995

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 31.

    McKneally MF: Ethical problems in surgery: innovation leading to unforeseen complications. World J Surg 23:7867881999McKneally MF: Ethical problems in surgery: innovation leading to unforeseen complications. World J Surg 23:786–788 1999

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 32.

    Meakins JL: Innovation in surgery: the rules of evidence. Am J Surg 183:3994052002Meakins JL: Innovation in surgery: the rules of evidence. Am J Surg 183:399–405 2002

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 33.

    Millesi WTruppe MWatzinger Fet al: Remote stereotactic visualization for image-guided surgery: technical innovation. J Craniomaxillofac Surg 25:1361381997Millesi W Truppe M Watzinger F et al: Remote stereotactic visualization for image-guided surgery: technical innovation. J Craniomaxillofac Surg 25:136–138 1997

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 34.

    Moore FD: Ethical problems special to surgery: surgical teaching, surgical innovation, and the surgeon in managed care. Arch Surg 135:14262000Moore FD: Ethical problems special to surgery: surgical teaching surgical innovation and the surgeon in managed care. Arch Surg 135:14–26 2000

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 35.

    Mosteller F: Innovation and evaluation. Science 211:8818861981Mosteller F: Innovation and evaluation. Science 211:881–886 1981

  • 36.

    National Commission for the Protection of Human Subjects of Biomedical and Behavioral Research: The Belmont Report: Ethical Principles and Guidelines for the Protection of Human Subjects of Research. Washington, DC: US Government Printing Office1978National Commission for the Protection of Human Subjects of Biomedical and Behavioral Research: The Belmont Report: Ethical Principles and Guidelines for the Protection of Human Subjects of Research. Washington DC: US Government Printing Office 1978

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 37.

    Nuremberg Military Tribunal: The Nuremberg Code. JAMA 276:16911996Nuremberg Military Tribunal: The Nuremberg Code. JAMA 276:1691 1996

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 38.

    Ramsay CRGrant AMWallace SAet al: Assessment of the learning curve in health technologies. A systematic review. Int J Technol Assess Health Care 16:109511082000Ramsay CR Grant AM Wallace SA et al: Assessment of the learning curve in health technologies. A systematic review. Int J Technol Assess Health Care 16:1095–1108 2000

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 39.

    Reemtsma KGelijns ACSisk JEet al: Supporting future surgical innovation. Lung transplantation as a case study. Ann Surg 218:4654751993Reemtsma K Gelijns AC Sisk JE et al: Supporting future surgical innovation. Lung transplantation as a case study. Ann Surg 218:465–475 1993

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 40.

    Reitsma AMMoreno JD: Ethical regulations for innovative surgery: the last frontier? J Am Coll Surg 194:7928012002Reitsma AM Moreno JD: Ethical regulations for innovative surgery: the last frontier? J Am Coll Surg 194:792–801 2002

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 41.

    Richardson DA: Ethics in gynecologic surgical innovation. Am J Obstet Gynecol 170:161994Richardson DA: Ethics in gynecologic surgical innovation. Am J Obstet Gynecol 170:1–6 1994

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 42.

    Roos LLSharp SM: Innovation, centralization, and growth. Coronary artery bypass graft surgery in Manitoba. Med Care 27:4414521989Roos LL Sharp SM: Innovation centralization and growth. Coronary artery bypass graft surgery in Manitoba. Med Care 27:441–452 1989

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 43.

    Ruit SPaudyal GGurung Ret al: An innovation in developing world cataract surgery: sutureless extracapsular cataract extraction with the intraocular lens implantation. Clin Exp Ophthalmol 28:2742792000Ruit S Paudyal G Gurung R et al: An innovation in developing world cataract surgery: sutureless extracapsular cataract extraction with the intraocular lens implantation. Clin Exp Ophthalmol 28:274–279 2000

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 44.

    Selker RGShapiro WRBurger Pet al: The Brain Tumor Cooperative Group NIH Trial 87—01: a randomized comparison of surgery, external radiotherapy, and carmustine versus surgery, interstitial radiotherapy boost, external radiation therapy, and carmustine. Neurosurgery 51:3433572002Selker RG Shapiro WR Burger P et al: The Brain Tumor Cooperative Group NIH Trial 87—01: a randomized comparison of surgery external radiotherapy and carmustine versus surgery interstitial radiotherapy boost external radiation therapy and carmustine. Neurosurgery 51:343–357 2002

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 45.

    Shaw E: Looking through the retrospectoscope in the era of evidence-based medicine. J Clin Oncol 15:128912901997Shaw E: Looking through the retrospectoscope in the era of evidence-based medicine. J Clin Oncol 15:1289–1290 1997

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 46.

    Slater EE: IRB reform. N Engl J Med 346:140214042002Slater EE: IRB reform. N Engl J Med 346:1402–1404 2002

  • 47.

    Steiger HJ: How to control the risk of novel surgical procedures. Acta Neurochir Suppl 78:1791842001Steiger HJ: How to control the risk of novel surgical procedures. Acta Neurochir Suppl 78:179–184 2001

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 48.

    Taylor MDBernstein M: Awake craniotomy with brain mapping as the routine surgical approach to treating patients with supratentorial intraaxial tumors: a prospective trial of 200 cases. J Neurosurg 90:35411999Taylor MD Bernstein M: Awake craniotomy with brain mapping as the routine surgical approach to treating patients with supratentorial intraaxial tumors: a prospective trial of 200 cases. J Neurosurg 90:35–41 1999

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 49.

    Taylor WAThomas NWWellings JAet al: Timing of postoperative intracranial hematoma development and implications for the best use of neurosurgical intensive care. J Neurosurg 82:48501995Taylor WA Thomas NW Wellings JA et al: Timing of postoperative intracranial hematoma development and implications for the best use of neurosurgical intensive care. J Neurosurg 82:48–50 1995

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 50.

    Wall LL: Innovation in surgery: caveat emptor. Int Urogynecol J Pelvic Floor Dysfunct 12:3533542001Wall LL: Innovation in surgery: caveat emptor. Int Urogynecol J Pelvic Floor Dysfunct 12:353–354 2001

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 51.

    Weijer C: Placebo trials and tribulations. Can Med Assoc J 166:6036042002Weijer C: Placebo trials and tribulations. Can Med Assoc J 166:603–604 2002

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 52.

    Williams RW: Microlumbar discectomy: a conservative surgical approach to the virgin herniated lumbar disc. Spine 3:1751821978Williams RW: Microlumbar discectomy: a conservative surgical approach to the virgin herniated lumbar disc. Spine 3:175–182 1978

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 53.

    Winter RB: Innovation in surgical technique. The story of spine surgery. Clin Orthop 378:9142000Winter RB: Innovation in surgical technique. The story of spine surgery. Clin Orthop 378:9–14 2000

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 54.

    World Medical Association Declaration of Helsinki: Ethical Principles for Medical Research Involving Human Subjects. Edinburgh: World Medical Association2000World Medical Association Declaration of Helsinki: Ethical Principles for Medical Research Involving Human Subjects. Edinburgh: World Medical Association 2000

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation

TrendMD

Cited By

Metrics

Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 197 197 9
Full Text Views 129 95 0
PDF Downloads 125 99 0
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0

PubMed

Google Scholar