There is contradictory evidence regarding the relative contribution of the key stabilizing ligaments of the occipitoatlantal (OA) joint. Cadaveric studies are limited by the nature and the number of injury scenarios that can be tested to identify OA stabilizing ligaments. Finite element (FE) analysis can overcome these limitations and provide valuable data in this area. The authors completed an FE analysis of 5 subject-specific craniocervical junction (CCJ) models to investigate the biomechanics of the OA joint and identify the ligamentous structures essential for stability.
Isolated and combined injury scenarios were simulated under physiological loads for 5 validated CCJ FE models to assess the relative role of key ligamentous structures on OA joint stability. Each model was tested in flexion-extension, axial rotation, and lateral bending in various injury scenarios. Isolated ligamentous injury scenarios consisted of either decreasing the stiffness of the OA capsular ligaments (OACLs) or completely removing the transverse ligament (TL), tectorial membrane (TM), or alar ligaments (ALs). Combination scenarios were also evaluated.
An isolated OACL injury resulted in the largest percentage increase in all ranges of motion (ROMs) at the OA joint compared with the other isolated injuries. Flexion, extension, lateral bending, and axial rotation significantly increased by 12.4% ± 7.4%, 11.1% ± 10.3%, 83.6% ± 14.4%, and 81.9% ± 9.4%, respectively (p ≤ 0.05 for all). Among combination injuries, OACL+TM+TL injury resulted in the most consistent significant increases in ROM for both the OA joint and the CCJ during all loading scenarios. OACL+AL injury caused the most significant percentage increase for OA joint axial rotation.
These results demonstrate that the OACLs are the key stabilizing ligamentous structures of the OA joint. Injury of these primary stabilizing ligaments is necessary to cause OA instability. Isolated injuries of TL, TM, or AL are unlikely to result in appreciable instability at the OA joint.
ABBREVIATIONSAA = atlantoaxial; AACL = AA capsular ligament; AL = alar ligament; AOD = atlantooccipital dislocation; CCI = condylar–C1 interval; CCJ = craniocervical junction; FE = finite element; FEM = FE method; OA = occipitoatlantal; OACL = OA capsular ligament; Oc = occiput; ROM = range of motion; TL = transverse ligament; TM = tectorial membrane.
BrowdSHealyLJDobieGJohnsonJTIIIJonesGMRodriguezLF: Morphometric and qualitative analysis of congenital occipitocervical instability in children: implications for patients with Down syndrome. J Neurosurg105 (1 Suppl):50–542006
BrowdSRMcIntyreJSBrockmeyerD: Failed age-dependent maturation of the occipital condyle in patients with congenital occipitoatlantal instability and Down syndrome: a preliminary analysis. J Neurosurg Pediatr2:359–3642008
ChildZRauDLeeMJChingRBransfordRChapmanJ: The provocative radiographic traction test for diagnosing craniocervical dissociation: a cadaveric biomechanical study and reappraisal of the pathogenesis of instability. Spine J16:1116–11232016
Gonzalez CarcedoMBrolinK: Generation of Numerical Human Models Based On Medical Imaging. Technical Research Report No. 2012:01. Gothenburg, Sweden: Chalmers University of Technology2012(http://publications.lib.chalmers.se/records/fulltext/local_155348.pdf) [Accessed November 13 2018]
KatoGKawaguchiKTsukamotoNKomiyamaKMizutaKOnoharaT: Recurrent dislocations of the atlantooccipital and atlantoaxial joints in a halo vest fixator are resolved by backrest elevation in an elevation angle-dependent manner. Spine J15:e69–e742015
PangDNemzekWRZovickianJ: Atlanto-occipital dislocation—part 2: The clinical use of (occipital) condyle-C1 interval, comparison with other diagnostic methods, and the manifestation, management, and outcome of atlanto-occipital dislocation in children. Neurosurgery61:995–10152007
RavindraVMRiva-CambrinJHornKPGinosJBrockmeyerRGuanJ: A 2D threshold of the condylar-C1 interval to maximize identification of patients at high risk for atlantooccipital dislocation using computed tomography. J Neurosurg Pediatr19:458–4632017
SongMZhangZLuMZongJDongCMaK: Four lateral mass screw fixation techniques in lower cervical spine following laminectomy: a finite element analysis study of stress distribution. Biomed Eng Online13:1152014