The chronic stinger syndrome is a distinct entity from acute stingers and has been shown to have its own pathophysiology that, unlike acute stingers, may reflect long-standing geometrical changes of the subaxial spinal canal and chronic irritation/degeneration of the exiting nerve root complex. There is no method available, however, to accurately predict these symptoms in athletes. The mean subaxial cervical space available for the cord (MSCSAC) is a novel alternative to the Torg ratio for predicting neurological symptoms caused by cervical spondylosis in elite athletes. It is the goal of this study to determine critical values for this measurement index and to retrospectively correlate those values to neurological symptoms.
Magnetic resonance images obtained in 103 male athletes participating in the 2005 and 2006 National Football League Scouting Combine and a control group of 42 age-matched male nonathletes were retrospectively reviewed. The Torg ratio and SAC values were calculated in triplicate at each cervical level from C3–6 by using lateral radiographs and midsagittal T2-weighted MR images of the cervical spine, respectively. These values were then averaged for each individual to produce mean subaxial cervical Torg ratio (MSCTR) and MSCSAC values. Receiver operating characteristic curves were constructed for each measurement technique and were compared based on their respective area under the curves (AUCs).
The MSCSAC difference between athletes with and without chronic stingers was statistically significant (p < 0.01). The difference between athletes with and without chronic stingers compared with controls was also statistically significant (p < 0.001 and p < 0.001, respectively). The AUC for the MSCSAC was 0.813, which was significantly greater than the AUC for both the MSCTR (p = 0.0475) and the individual Torg ratio (p = 0.0277). The MSCTR had the second largest AUC (0.676) and the conventional method of measuring individual Torg ratio values produced the lowest AUC (0.661). It was found that using the MSCSAC with a critical value of 5.0 mm produced a sensitivity of 80% and a negative likelihood ratio of 0.23 for predicting chronic stingers. Lowering the cutoff value to 4.3 mm for the MSCSAC resulted in a possible confirmatory test with a specificity of 96% and a positive likelihood ratio of 13.25.
A critical value of 5.0 mm for the MSCSAC provides the clinician with a screening test for chronic stingers and anything < 4.3 mm adds additional confidence as a confirmatory test. These results are ~ 20% more accurate than the classic Torg ratio based on our AUC analysis. It was found that measuring the spinal geometry throughout the length of the subaxial cervical spine produced a more reliable method by which to predict neurological symptoms than the traditional approach of measuring individual levels. This shows that the underlying pathogenesis of the chronic stinger syndrome is best characterized as a process that involves the entire subaxial region uniformly.
Abbreviations used in this paper:
AUC = area under their curve; MSCSAC = mean subaxial cervical space available for the cord; MSCTR = mean subaxial cervical Torg ratio; NFL = National Football League; ROC = receiver operating characteristic; SAC = space available for the cord; VB = vertebral body.
HerzogRJ, , WiensJJ, , DillinghamMF, & SontagMJ: Normal cervical spine morphometry and cervical spinal stenosis in asymptomatic professional football players: plain film radiography, multiplanar computed tomography, and magnetic resonance imaging. Spine16:S178–S186, 1991
HerzogRJ, WiensJJ, DillinghamMF, SontagMJ: Normal cervical spine morphometry and cervical spinal stenosis in asymptomatic professional football players: plain film radiography, multiplanar computed tomography, and magnetic resonance imaging. Spine16:S178–S186, 199110.1097/00007632-199106001-00001)| false
LurieJD, TostesonAN, TostesonTD, CarrageeE, CarrinoJA, KaiserJ, : Reliability of readings of magnetic resonance imaging features of lumbar spinal stenosis. Spine33:1605–1610, 200810.1097/BRS.0b013e3181791af3)| false
TorgJS, , NaranjaRJJr, , PavlovH, , GalinatBJ, , WarrenR, & StineRA: The relationship of developmental narrowing of the cervical spinal canal to reversible and irreversible injury of the cervical spinal cord in football players. J Bone Joint Surg Am78:1308–1314, 1996
TorgJS, NaranjaRJJr, PavlovH, GalinatBJ, WarrenR, StineRA: The relationship of developmental narrowing of the cervical spinal canal to reversible and irreversible injury of the cervical spinal cord in football players. J Bone Joint Surg Am78:1308–1314, 199610.2106/00004623-199609000-00003)| false
WeinsteinSM: Assessment and rehabilitation of the athlete with a “stinger.” A model for the management of noncatastrophic athletic cervical spine injury. Clin Sports Med17:127–135, 199810.1016/S0278-5919(05)70067-3)| false