Falls are the most common environmental setting for closed head injuries in children between 2 and 4 years of age. The authors previously found that toddlers had fewer skull fractures and scalp/facial soft-tissue injuries, and more frequent altered mental status than infants for the same low-height falls (≤3 ft).
To identify potential age-dependent mechanical load factors that may be responsible for these clinical findings, the authors created an instrumented dummy representing an 18-month-old child using published toddler anthropometry and mechanical properties of the skull and neck, and they measured peak angular acceleration during low-height falls (1, 2, and 3 ft) onto carpet pad and concrete. They compared these results from occiput-first impacts to previously obtained values measured in a 6-week-old infant dummy.
Peak angular acceleration of the toddler dummy head was largest in the sagittal and horizontal directions and increased significantly (around 2-fold) with fall height between 1 and 2 ft. Impacts onto concrete produced larger peak angular accelerations and smaller impact durations than those onto carpet pad. When compared with previously measured infant drops, toddler head accelerations were more than double those of the infant from the same height onto the same surface, likely contributing to the higher incidence of loss of consciousness reported in toddlers. Furthermore, the toddler impact forces were larger than those in the infant, but because of the thicker toddler skull, the risk of skull fracture from low-height falls is likely lower in toddlers compared with infants.
If similar fracture limits and brain tissue injury thresholds between infants and toddlers are assumed, it is expected that for impact events, the toddler is likely less vulnerable to skull fracture but more vulnerable to neurological impairment compared with the infant.
Abbreviations used in this paper: CRABI = child restraint air bag interaction; HIC = head injury criterion; HIC15 = HIC with a maximum time interval of 15 msec; HIC36 = HIC with a maximum time interval of 36 msec.
Address correspondence to: Susan S. Margulies, Ph.D., Department of Bioengineering, The University of Pennsylvania, 240 Skirkanich Hall, 210 South 33rd Street, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19104-6321. email:
CoryCZJonesMD: Development of a simulation system for performing in situ surface tests to assess the potential severity of head impacts from alleged childhood short falls. Forensic Sci Int163:102–1142006
EppingerRHSunEBandakFAHaffnerMKhaewpongNMalteseMR: Development of Improved Injury Criteria for the Assessment of Advance Automotive Restraint Systems— IIWashington, DCNational Highway Traffic Safety Administration2000
IbrahimNG: Head injury biomechanics in toddlers: integrated clinical, anthropomorphic dummy, animal and finite element model studies. Bioengineering [dissertation]PhiladelphiaUniversity of Pennsylvania2009
KleinbergerMSunEEppingerRKuppaSSaulR: Development of Improved Injury Criteria for the Assessment of Advanced Automotive Restraint SystemsWashington, DCNational Highway Traffic Safety Administration1998
OmmayaAKYarnellPHirschAEHarrisEH: Scaling of experimental data on cerebral concussion in sub-human primates to concussion threshold for man. Proceedings of 11th Stapp Car Crash ConferenceLos Angeles, CASociety of Automotive Engineers1967. 73–80
PincemailleYTrosseilleXMackPBrun-CassanFTarriereCRenaultB: Investigation of Relationships Between Physical Parameters and Neurophysiological Response to Head Impact. Final ReportWashington, DCDOT contract DTRS-57-86-C-000371988