A systematic review of evaluation methods for neonatal brachial plexus palsy

A review

Restricted access

Object

Neonatal brachial plexus palsy (NBPP) affects 0.4–2.6 newborns per 1000 live births in the US. Many infants recover spontaneously, but for those without spontaneous recovery, nerve and/or secondary musculoskeletal reconstruction can restore function to the affected arm. This condition not only manifests in a paretic/paralyzed arm, but also affects the overall health and psychosocial condition of the children and their parents. Currently, measurement instruments for NBPP focus primarily on physical ability, with limited information regarding the effect of the disablement on activities of daily living and the child's psychosocial well-being. It is also difficult to assess and compare overall treatment efficacy among medical (conservative) or surgical management strategies without consistent use of evaluation instruments. The purpose of this study is to review the reported measurement evaluation methods for NBPP in an attempt to provide recommendations for future measurement usage and development.

Methods

The authors systematically reviewed the literature published between January 1980 and February 2012 using multiple databases to search the keywords “brachial plexus” and “obstetric” or “pediatrics” or “neonatal” or “congenital.” Original articles with primary patient outcomes were included in the data summary. Four types of evaluation methods (classification, diagnostics, physical assessment, and functional outcome) were distinguished among treatment management groups. Descriptive statistics and 1-way ANOVA were applied to compare the data summaries among specific groups.

Results

Of 2836 articles initially identified, 307 were included in the analysis, with 198 articles (9646 patients) reporting results after surgical treatment, 70 articles (4434 patients) reporting results after medical treatment, and 39 articles (4247 patients) reporting results after combined surgical and medical treatment. Among medical practitioners who treat NBPP, there was equivalence in usage of classification, diagnostic, and physical assessment tools (that focused on the Body Function and Structures measure of the International Classification of Functioning, Disability, and Health [ICF]). However, there was discordance in the functional outcome measures that focus on ICF levels of Activity and Participation. Of the 126 reported evaluation methods, only a few (the Active Movement Scale, Toronto Scale Score, Mallet Scale, Assisting Hand Assessment, and Pediatric Outcomes Data Collection Instrument) are specifically validated for evaluating the NBPP population.

Conclusions

In this review, the authors demonstrate disparities in the use of NBPP evaluation instruments in the current literature. Additionally, valid and reliable evaluation instruments specifically for the NBPP population are significantly lacking, manifesting in difficulties with evaluating the overall impact and effectiveness of clinical treatments in a consistent and comparative manner, extending across the various subspecialties that are involved in the treatment of patients with NBPP. The authors suggest that all ICF domains should be considered, and future efforts should include consideration of spontaneous (not practitioner-elicited) use of the affected arm in activities of daily living with attention to the psychosocial impact of the disablement.

Abbreviations used in this paper:ADLs = activities of daily living; EMG = electromyography; ICF = International Classification of Functioning, Disability, and Health; MRC = Medical Research Council; NBPP = neonatal brachial plexus palsy; ROM = range of motion; WeeFIM = Functional Independence Measure for Children.

Article Information

* Ms. Chang and Ms. Justice contributed equally to this work.

Address correspondence to: Lynda J. S. Yang, M.D., Ph.D., Department of Neurosurgery, University of Michigan, 1500 E. Medical Center Dr., Rm. 3552 TC, Ann Arbor, MI 48109-5338. email: ljsyang@med.umich.edu.

Please include this information when citing this paper: published online August 9, 2013; DOI: 10.3171/2013.6.PEDS12630.

© AANS, except where prohibited by US copyright law.

Headings

Figures

  • View in gallery

    Flowchart of primary database search including number of articles retrieved and excluded from review.

  • View in gallery

    Flowchart illustrating interaction of the ICF domains.

References

1

Al-Qattan MMEl-Sayed AAAl-Zahrani AYAl-Mutairi SAAl-Harbi MSAl-Mutairi AM: Narakas classification of obstetric brachial plexus palsy revisited. J Hand Surg Eur Vol 34:7887912009

2

Bae DSWaters PMZurakowski D: Correlation of pediatric outcomes data collection instrument with measures of active movement in children with brachial plexus birth palsy. J Pediatr Orthop 28:5845922008

3

Bae DSWaters PMZurakowski D: Reliability of three classification systems measuring active motion in brachial plexus birth palsy. J Bone Joint Surg Am 85-A:173317382003

4

Bae DSZurakowski DAvallone NYu RWaters PM: Sports participation in selected children with brachial plexus birth palsy. J Pediatr Orthop 29:4965032009

5

Bahm JOcampo-Pavez CDisselhorst-Klug CSellhaus BWeis J: Obstetric brachial plexus palsy: treatment strategy, long-term results, and prognosis. Dtsch Arztebl Int 106:83902009

6

Berg MJahnsen RFrøslie KFHussain A: Reliability of the Pediatric Evaluation of Disability Inventory (PEDI). Phys Occup Ther Pediatr 24:61772004

7

Bertelli JAGhizoni MF: The towel test: a useful technique for the clinical and electromyographic evaluation of obstetric brachial plexus palsy. J Hand Surg Br 29:1551582004

8

Bolanos AABleck EEFirestone PYoung L: Comparison of stereognosis and two-point discrimination testing of the hands of children with cerebral palsy. Dev Med Child Neurol 31:3713761989

9

Borschel GHClarke HM: Obstetrical brachial plexus palsy. Plast Reconstr Surg 124:1 Suppl144e155e2009

10

Carlozzi NETulsky DS: Identification of health-related quality of life (HRQOL) issues relevant to individuals with Huntington disease. J Health Psychol 18:2122252013

11

Carlozzi NETulsky DSKisala PA: Traumatic brain injury patient-reported outcome measure: identification of health-related quality-of-life issues relevant to individuals with traumatic brain injury. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 92:10 SupplS52S602011

12

Chuang DCMa HSWei FC: A new evaluation system to predict the sequelae of late obstetric brachial plexus palsy. Plast Reconstr Surg 101:6736851998

13

Clarke HMCurtis CG: An approach to obstetrical brachial plexus injuries. Hand Clin 11:5635811995

14

Curtis CStephens DClarke HMAndrews D: The active movement scale: an evaluative tool for infants with obstetrical brachial plexus palsy. J Hand Surg Am 27:4704782002

15

Daltroy LHLiang MHFossel AHGoldberg MJ: The POSNA pediatric musculoskeletal functional health questionnaire: report on reliability, validity, and sensitivity to change. J Pediatr Orthop 18:5615711998

16

Dedini RDBagley AMMolitor FJames MA: Comparison of pediatric outcomes data collection instrument scores and range of motion before and after shoulder tendon transfers for children with brachial plexus birth palsy. J Pediatr Orthop 28:2592642008

17

Eng GDBinder HGetson PO'Donnell R: Obstetrical brachial plexus palsy (OBPP) outcome with conservative management. Muscle Nerve 19:8848911996

18

Foad SLMehlman CTYing J: The epidemiology of neonatal brachial plexus palsy in the United States. J Bone Joint Surg Am 90:125812642008

19

Gilbert A: Brachial Plexus Injuries LondonMartin Dunitz2001

20

Greenwald AGSchute PCShiveley JL: Brachial plexus birth palsy: a 10-year report on the incidence and prognosis. J Pediatr Orthop 4:6896921984

21

Haerle M: [Standardization of evaluation and classification of disability manifestations in traumatic brachial plexus birth injury-induced paralysis.]. Orthopade 26:7197221997. (Ger)

22

Haerle MGilbert A: Management of complete obstetric brachial plexus lesions. J Pediatr Orthop 24:1942002004

23

Hale HBBae DSWaters PM: Current concepts in the management of brachial plexus birth palsy. J Hand Surg Am 35:3223312010

24

Haley SM: Pediatric Evaluation of Disability Inventory (PEDI):Development Standardization and Administration Manual Version 1.0 BostonNew England Medical Center Hospitals1992

25

Heise COSiqueira MGMartins RSGherpelli JL: Motor nerve-conduction studies in obstetric brachial plexopathy for a selection of patients with a poor outcome. J Bone Joint Surg Am 91:172917372009

26

Ho ESCurtis CGClarke HM: The brachial plexus outcome measure: development, internal consistency, and construct validity. J Hand Ther 25:4064162012

27

Ho ESCurtis CGClarke HM: Pediatric Evaluation of Disability Inventory: its application to children with obstetric brachial plexus palsy. J Hand Surg Am 31:1972022006

28

Holmefur MKrumlinde-Sundholm LEliasson AC: Interrater and intrarater reliability of the Assisting Hand Assessment. Am J Occup Ther 61:79842007

29

Huffman GRBagley AMJames MALerman JARab G: Assessment of children with brachial plexus birth palsy using the Pediatric Outcomes Data Collection Instrument. J Pediatr Orthop 25:4004042005

30

Immerman IAlfonso DTRamos LEGrossman LAAlfonso IDitaranto P: Hand function in children with an upper brachial plexus birth injury: results of the nine-hole peg test. Dev Med Child Neurol 54:1661692012

31

James MA: Use of the Medical Research Council muscle strength grading system in the upper extremity. J Hand Surg Am 32:1541562007

32

Krumlinde-Sundholm LHolmefur MKottorp AEliasson AC: The Assisting Hand Assessment: current evidence of validity, reliability, and responsiveness to change. Dev Med Child Neurol 49:2592642007

33

Landgraf JMAbetz LWare JE: Child Health Questionnaire (CHQ): A User's Manual BostonHealth Act1999

34

Lemmens RJTimmermans AAJanssen-Potten YJSmeets RJSeelen HA: Valid and reliable instruments for arm-hand assessment at ICF activity level in persons with hemiplegia: a systematic review. BMC Neurol 12:212012

35

Levine MGHolroyde JWoods JR JrSiddiqi TAScott MMiodovnik M: Birth trauma: incidence and predisposing factors. Obstet Gynecol 63:7927951984

36

Lollar DJSimeonsson RJ: Diagnosis to function: classification for children and youths. J Dev Behav Pediatr 26:3233302005

37

Mallet J: [Obstetrical paralysis of the brachial plexus. II. Therapeutics. Treatment of sequelae. Priority for the treatment of the shoulder. Method for the expression of results.]. Rev Chir Orthop Repar Appar Mot 58:Suppl 11661681972. (Fr)

38

Marcus JRClarke HM: Management of obstetrical brachial plexus palsy evaluation, prognosis, and primary surgical treatment. Clin Plast Surg 30:2893062003

39

McDougall JWright V: The ICF-CY and Goal Attainment Scaling: benefits of their combined use for pediatric practice. Disabil Rehabil 31:136213722009

40

Medical Research Council: Aids to the Examination of the Peripheral Nervous System Memorandum no. 45 LondonHer Majesty's Stationery Office1981

41

Michelow BJClarke HMCurtis CGZuker RMSeifu YAndrews DF: The natural history of obstetrical brachial plexus palsy. Plast Reconstr Surg 93:6756811994

42

Pondaag WMalessy MJvan Dijk JGThomeer RT: Natural history of obstetric brachial plexus palsy: a systematic review. Dev Med Child Neurol 46:1381442004

43

Rahlin MCech DRheault WStoecker J: Use of music during physical therapy intervention for an infant with Erb's palsy: a single-subject design. Physiother Theory Pract 23:1051172007

44

Rahlin MRheault WCech D: Evaluation of the primary subtests of toddler and infant motor evaluation: implications for clinical practice in pediatric physical therapy. Pediatr Phys Ther 15:1761832003

45

Rosenbaum PStewart D: The World Health Organization International Classification of Functioning, Disability, and Health: a model to guide clinical thinking, practice and research in the field of cerebral palsy. Semin Pediatr Neurol 11:5102004

46

Rosenbaum PLWalter SDHanna SEPalisano RJRussell DJRaina P: Prognosis for gross motor function in cerebral palsy: creation of motor development curves. JAMA 288:135713632002

47

Sebastin SJChung KC: Pathogenesis and management of deformities of the elbow, wrist, and hand in late neonatal brachial plexus palsy. J Pediatr Rehabil Med 4:1191302011

48

Sköld AHermansson LNKrumlinde-Sundholm LEliasson AC: Development and evidence of validity for the Children's Hand-Use Experience Questionnaire (CHEQ). Dev Med Child Neurol 53:4364422011

49

Smith YAHong EPresson C: Normative and validation studies of the Nine-Hole Peg Test with children. Percept Mot Skills 90:8238432000

50

Squitieri LLarson BPChang KWYang LJChung KC: Medical decision-making among adolescents with neonatal brachial plexus palsy and their families: a qualitative study. Plast Reconstr Surg 131:880e887e2013

51

Squitieri LSteggerda JYang LJKim HMChung KC: A national study to evaluate trends in the utilization of nerve reconstruction for treatment of neonatal brachial plexus palsy [outcomes article]. Plast Reconstr Surg 127:2772832011. PubMed

52

Strömbeck CKrumlinde-Sundholm LRemahl SSejersen T: Long-term follow-up of children with obstetric brachial plexus palsy I: functional aspects. Dev Med Child Neurol 49:1982032007

53

Sunderland S: A classification of peripheral nerve injuries producing loss of function. Brain 74:4915161951

54

Terzis JKPapakonstantinou KC: Management of obstetric brachial plexus palsy. Hand Clin 15:7177361999

55

Tulsky DSCarlozzi NECella D: Advances in outcomes measurement in rehabilitation medicine: current initiatives from the National Institutes of Health and the National Institute on Disability and Rehabilitation Research. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 92:10 SupplS1S62011

56

Venkatramani HBhardwaj PFaruquee SRSabapathy SR: Functional outcome of nerve transfer for restoration of shoulder and elbow function in upper brachial plexus injury. J Brachial Plex Peripher Nerve Inj 3:152008

57

Wagner LVDavids JR: Assessment tools and classification systems used for the upper extremity in children with cerebral palsy. Clin Orthop Relat Res 470:125712712012

58

Waters PM: Comparison of the natural history, the outcome of microsurgical repair, and the outcome of operative reconstruction in brachial plexus birth palsy. J Bone Joint Surg Am 81:6496591999

59

Waters PM: Management of shoulder deformities in brachial plexus birth palsies. J Pediatr Orthop 30:S53S562010

60

Waters PM: Update on management of pediatric brachial plexus palsy. J Pediatr Orthop B 14:2332442005

61

World Health Organization: International Classification of Functioning Disability and Health: ICF Short Version GenevaWorld Health Organization2001

TrendMD

Metrics

Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 108 108 33
Full Text Views 88 88 7
PDF Downloads 215 215 17
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0

PubMed

Google Scholar