Common surgical treatments for trigeminal neuralgia (TN) include microvascular decompression (MVD), stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS), and radiofrequency ablation (RFA). Although the efficacy of each procedure has been described, few studies have directly compared these treatment modalities on pain control for TN. Using a large prospective longitudinal database, the authors aimed to 1) directly compare long-term pain control rates for first-time surgical treatments for idiopathic TN, and 2) identify predictors of pain control.
The authors reviewed a prospectively collected database for all patients who underwent treatment for TN between 1997 and 2014 at the University of California, San Francisco. Standardized collection of data on preoperative clinical characteristics, surgical procedure, and postoperative outcomes was performed. Data analyses were limited to those patients who received a first-time procedure for treatment of idiopathic TN with > 1 year of follow-up.
Of 764 surgical procedures performed at the University of California, San Francisco, for TN (364 SRS, 316 MVD, and 84 RFA), 340 patients underwent first-time treatment for idiopathic TN (164 MVD, 168 SRS, and 8 RFA) and had > 1 year of follow-up. The analysis was restricted to patients who underwent MVD or SRS. Patients who received MVD were younger than those who underwent SRS (median age 63 vs 72 years, respectively; p < 0.001). The mean follow-up was 59 ± 35 months for MVD and 59 ± 45 months for SRS. Approximately 38% of patients who underwent MVD or SRS had > 5 years of follow-up (60 of 164 and 64 of 168 patients, respectively). Immediate or short-term (< 3 months) postoperative pain-free rates (Barrow Neurological Institute Pain Intensity score of I) were 96% for MVD and 75% for SRS. Percentages of patients with Barrow Neurological Institute Pain Intensity score of I at 1, 5, and 10 years after MVD were 83%, 61%, and 44%, and the corresponding percentages after SRS were 71%, 47%, and 27%, respectively. The median time to pain recurrence was 94 months (25th–75th quartiles: 57–131 months) for MVD and 53 months (25th–75th quartiles: 37–69 months) for SRS (p = 0.006). A subset of patients who had MVD also underwent partial sensory rhizotomy, usually in the setting of insignificant vascular compression. Compared with MVD alone, those who underwent MVD plus partial sensory rhizotomy had shorter pain-free intervals (median 45 months vs no median reached; p = 0.022). Multivariable regression demonstrated that shorter preoperative symptom duration (HR 1.005, 95% CI 1.001–1.008; p = 0.006) was associated with favorable outcome for MVD and that post-SRS sensory changes (HR 0.392, 95% CI 0.213–0.723; p = 0.003) were associated with favorable outcome for SRS.
In this longitudinal study, patients who received MVD had longer pain-free intervals compared with those who underwent SRS. For patients who received SRS, postoperative sensory change was predictive of favorable outcome. However, surgical decision making depends upon many factors. This information can help physicians counsel patients with idiopathic TN on treatment selection.
Correspondence Edward F. Chang, Department of Neurological Surgery, University of California, San Francisco, 505 Parnassus Ave., M779, San Francisco, CA 94143-0112. email: firstname.lastname@example.org.INCLUDE WHEN CITING Published online February 24, 2017; DOI: 10.3171/2016.9.JNS16149.
Drs. Wang and Raygor contributed equally to this work.
Disclosures The authors report no conflict of interest concerning the materials or methods used in this study or the findings specified in this paper.
DhopleAAAdamsJRMaggioWWNaqviSARegineWFKwokY: Long-term outcomes of Gamma Knife radiosurgery for classic trigeminal neuralgia: implications of treatment and critical review of the literature. Clinical article. J Neurosurg111:351–3582009
DhopleAA, AdamsJR, MaggioWW, NaqviSA, RegineWF, KwokY: Long-term outcomes of Gamma Knife radiosurgery for classic trigeminal neuralgia: implications of treatment and critical review of the literature. Clinical article. 111:351–358, 20091932698710.3171/2009.2.JNS08977)| false
KanpolatYSavasABekarABerkC: Percutaneous controlled radiofrequency trigeminal rhizotomy for the treatment of idiopathic trigeminal neuralgia: 25-year experience with 1,600 patients. Neurosurgery48:524–5342001
KoopmanJS, de VriesLM, DielemanJP, HuygenFJ, StrickerBH, SturkenboomMC: A nationwide study of three invasive treatments for trigeminal neuralgia. 152:507–513, 201110.1016/j.pain.2010.10.04921239113)| false
LinskeyME, RatanatharathornV, PeñagaricanoJ: A prospective cohort study of microvascular decompression and Gamma Knife surgery in patients with trigeminal neuralgia. 109:Suppl160–172, 200810.3171/JNS/2008/109/12/S2519123904)| false
MillerJPAcarFBurchielKJ: Classification of trigeminal neuralgia: clinical, therapeutic, and prognostic implications in a series of 144 patients undergoing microvascular decompression. J Neurosurg111:1231–12342009
MillerJP, AcarF, BurchielKJ: Classification of trigeminal neuralgia: clinical, therapeutic, and prognostic implications in a series of 144 patients undergoing microvascular decompression. 111:1231–1234, 200910.3171/2008.6.17604)| false
MontanoNPapacciFCioniBDi BonaventuraRMeglioM: The role of percutaneous balloon compression in the treatment of trigeminal neuralgia recurring after other surgical procedures. Acta Neurol Belg114:59–642014
MontanoN, PapacciF, CioniB, Di BonaventuraR, MeglioM: The role of percutaneous balloon compression in the treatment of trigeminal neuralgia recurring after other surgical procedures. 114:59–64, 20142433875910.1007/s13760-013-0263-x)| false
PollockBESchoeberlKA: Prospective comparison of posterior fossa exploration and stereotactic radiosurgery dorsal root entry zone target as primary surgery for patients with idiopathic trigeminal neuralgia. Neurosurgery67:633–6392010
PollockBE, SchoeberlKA: Prospective comparison of posterior fossa exploration and stereotactic radiosurgery dorsal root entry zone target as primary surgery for patients with idiopathic trigeminal neuralgia. 67:633–639, 20102064796210.1227/01.NEU.0000377861.14650.98)| false
RégisJTuleascaCResseguierNCarronRDonnetAGaudartJ: Long-term safety and efficacy of Gamma Knife surgery in classical trigeminal neuralgia: a 497-patient historical cohort study. J Neurosurg124:1079–10872016
RiesenburgerRI, HwangSW, SchirmerCM, ZerrisV, WuJK, MahnK, : Outcomes following single-treatment Gamma Knife surgery for trigeminal neuralgia with a minimum 3-year follow-up. 112:766–771, 20101978064410.3171/2009.8.JNS081706)| false
RogersCLShetterAGFiedlerJASmithKAHanPPSpeiserBL: Gamma Knife radiosurgery for trigeminal neuralgia: the initial experience of The Barrow Neurological Institute. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys47:1013–10192000
RogersCL, ShetterAG, FiedlerJA, SmithKA, HanPP, SpeiserBL: Gamma Knife radiosurgery for trigeminal neuralgia: the initial experience of The Barrow Neurological Institute. 47:1013–1019, 20001086307310.1016/S0360-3016(00)00513-7)| false
RughaniAI, DumontTM, LinCT, TranmerBI, HorganMA: Safety of microvascular decompression for trigeminal neuralgia in the elderly. Clinical article. 115:202–209, 20112156865810.3171/2011.4.JNS101924)| false
SekulaRFJrFredericksonAMJannettaPJQuigleyMRAzizKMArnoneGD: Microvascular decompression for elderly patients with trigeminal neuralgia: a prospective study and systematic review with meta-analysis. J Neurosurg114:172–1792011
SekulaRFJr, FredericksonAM, JannettaPJ, QuigleyMR, AzizKM, ArnoneGD: Microvascular decompression for elderly patients with trigeminal neuralgia: a prospective study and systematic review with meta-analysis. 114:172–179, 201110.3171/2010.6.JNS1014220653393)| false
SindouMLestonJMDecullierEChapuisF: Microvascular decompression for trigeminal neuralgia: the importance of a noncompressive technique—Kaplan-Meier analysis in a consecutive series of 330 patients. Neurosurgery63:4 Suppl 2341–3512008
SindouM, LestonJM, DecullierE, ChapuisF: Microvascular decompression for trigeminal neuralgia: the importance of a noncompressive technique—Kaplan-Meier analysis in a consecutive series of 330 patients. 63:4 Suppl 2341–351, 2008)| false
TronnierVMRascheDHamerJKienleALKunzeS: Treatment of idiopathic trigeminal neuralgia: comparison of long-term outcome after radiofrequency rhizotomy and microvascular decompression. Neurosurgery48:1261–12682001
Tyler-KabaraECKassamABHorowitzMHUrgoLHadjipanayisCLevyEI: Predictors of outcome in surgically managed patients with typical and atypical trigeminal neuralgia: comparison of results following microvascular decompression. J Neurosurg96:527–5312002
Tyler-KabaraEC, KassamAB, HorowitzMH, UrgoL, HadjipanayisC, LevyEI, : Predictors of outcome in surgically managed patients with typical and atypical trigeminal neuralgia: comparison of results following microvascular decompression. 96:527–531, 200210.3171/jns.2002.96.3.052711883838)| false
van LoverenHTewJMJrKellerJTNurreMA: a 10-year experience in the treatment of trigeminal neuralgia. Comparison of percutaneous stereotaxic rhizotomy and posterior fossa exploration. J Neurosurg57:757–7641982
van LoverenH, TewJMJr, KellerJT, NurreMA: a 10-year experience in the treatment of trigeminal neuralgia. Comparison of percutaneous stereotaxic rhizotomy and posterior fossa exploration. 57:757–764, 198210.3171/jns.1982.57.6.0757)| false