In spite of ample literature pointing to rotational and combined impact dosage being key contributors to head and neck injury, boxing and mixed martial arts (MMA) padding is still designed to primarily reduce cranium linear acceleration. The objects of this study were to quantify preliminary linear and rotational head impact dosage for selected boxing and MMA padding in response to hook punches; compute theoretical skull, brain, and neck injury risk metrics; and statistically compare the protective effect of various glove and head padding conditions.
An instrumented Hybrid III 50th percentile anthropomorphic test device (ATD) was struck in 54 pendulum impacts replicating hook punches at low (27–29 J) and high (54–58 J) energy. Five padding combinations were examined: unpadded (control), MMA glove–unpadded head, boxing glove–unpadded head, unpadded pendulum–boxing headgear, and boxing glove–boxing headgear. A total of 17 injury risk parameters were measured or calculated.
All padding conditions reduced linear impact dosage. Other parameters significantly decreased, significantly increased, or were unaffected depending on padding condition. Of real-world conditions (MMA glove–bare head, boxing glove–bare head, and boxing glove–headgear), the boxing glove–headgear condition showed the most meaningful reduction in most of the parameters. In equivalent impacts, the MMA glove–bare head condition induced higher rotational dosage than the boxing glove–bare head condition. Finite element analysis indicated a risk of brain strain injury in spite of significant reduction of linear impact dosage.
In the replicated hook punch impacts, all padding conditions reduced linear but not rotational impact dosage. Head and neck dosage theoretically accumulates fastest in MMA and boxing bouts without use of protective headgear. The boxing glove–headgear condition provided the best overall reduction in impact dosage. More work is needed to develop improved protective padding to minimize linear and rotational impact dosage and develop next-generation standards for head and neck injury risk.
Abbreviations used in this paper:ATD = anthropomorphic test device; CSDM05 = cumulative strain damage measure at the 0.05 level; DDM = dilatational damage measure; GAMBIT = Generalized Acceleration Model for Brain Injury Threshold; GSI = Gadd Severity Index; HIC = Head Injury Criterion; HIP = head impact power; MMA = mixed martial arts; RMDM = relative motion damage measure; SIMon = Simulated Injury Monitor; wPCS = weighted principle component score.
American Society for Testing and Materials: Standard Test Methods for Equipment and Procedures Used in Evaluating the Performance Characteristics of Protective Headgear. Designation: F1446-01aWest Conshohocken, PAASTM International2002
BandakFAZhangAXTannousREDiMasiFMasielloPEppingerR: SIMon: a simulated injury monitor; application to head injury assessment. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) Website(http://www-nrd.nhtsa.dot.gov/pdf/esv/esv17/proceed/00222.pdf) [Accessed January 12 2012]
National Operating Committee on Standards for Athletic Equipment (NOCSAE): Standard test method and equipment used in evaluating the performance characteristics of protective headgear/equipment. NOCSAE Website(http://www.nocsae.org/standards/pdfs/Standards%20'10/ND001-08m10-Drop%20Impact%20Test%20Method%20.pdf) [Accessed January 12 2012]
NewmanJABeusenbergMCShewchenkoNWithnallCFournierE: Verification of biomechanical methods employed in a comprehensive study of mild traumatic brain injury and the effectiveness of American football helmets. J Biomech38:1469–14812005
NewmanJAShewchenkoNWelbourneE: A proposed new biomechanical head injury assessment function—the maximum power index. Snell Memorial Foundation Website(http://www.smf.org/docs/articles/hic/Newman_Max_Power_Index.pdf) [Accessed January 12 2012]
SmithTABishopPJWellsRP: Three dimensional analysis of linear and angular accelerations of the head experienced in boxing. Proceedings of the International Research Council on Biomechanics of ImpactVol 1:Bergish-Gladbach, GermanyIRCOBI1973–1989271–286