Harvey Cushing, perhaps the most important founder of American neurosurgery, was an Army neurosurgeon in France from 1917 to 1918. Over a 3-month period in 1917 he and his team operated on 133 soldiers with a brain wound. The operative mortality rate for their last 45 patients was 29%, considerably lower than the usual postoperative mortality rate of approximately 50% for those with a brain wound. This accomplishment was lauded at the time and eventually, for some, it was Cushing who was responsible for lowering the postoperative mortality rate of brain wounds during World War I. As the decades passed he was eventually credited as the “originator of brain wound care.” This report shows that these attributions are misplaced. Cushing merely followed the enlightened surgical precepts of the time developed by Continental (European) surgeons. It also examines Cushing's writings to ascertain how these misperceptions concerning his originality might have been generated.
Abbreviations used in this paper: BJS = British Journal of Surgery; BMJ = British Medical Journal; WW = World War.
AdieWJWagstaffeWW: A Note on a Series of 656 Cases of Gunshot Wound of the Head With a Statistical Consideration of the Results Obtained. Medical Research Committee Statistical Reports No. 1LondonH. M. Stationery Office1918
BrandvoldBLeviLFeinsodMGeorgeED: Penetrating craniocerebral injuries in the Israeli involvement in the Lebanese conflict, 1982–1985. Analysis of a less aggressive surgical approach. J Neurosurg72:15–211990
Comptes-Rendus de la Conférence Chirurgicale Interalliée Pour L'Étude des Plaies de Guerre: 7e Séance, 18 Mai 1917, 15e Question—Blessures du Cerveau; Conclusions sur les blessures du cerveu. Archiv de Méd et de Pharm Milit T68:451–4521917
DuvalP: Traitement des plaies de guerre de genou, sans lésions osseuses ou avec fractures intra-articulaires (grand fracas exceptés) par l'arthrotomie large, systématique et la fermeture totale de l'articulation, à l' Auto-chir. 21. Bull Mem Soc Chir Paris42:2229–22471916
LynchCGeneral introduction I, evolution of the medical department. LynchCWeedFWMcAfeeL: The Medical Department of the United States Army in the World War: The Surgeon General's OfficeWashington, DCGovernment Printing Office1923. I:82–83
MeirowskyAMPenetrating wounds of the brain. CoatesJBMeirowskyAM: Neurological Surgery of TraumaWashington, DCOffice of the Surgeon General, Department of the Army, US Government Printing Office1965. 103–130